Deputy FM responds to industry letter on business rates
General NewsDeputy First Minister and interim Finance Secretary, John Swinney MSP, has responded to an industry letter calling on the Scottish Government to freeze business rates in the forthcoming Scottish budget statement on 15 December.
Nineteen leading business representative groups and industry bodies, including Scottish Land & Estates and spearheaded by the Scottish Retail Consortium, wrote jointly to Mr Swinney in November, asking him to freeze non-domestic rates in the 2023-24 financial year. In the UK Government’s Autumn Statement the Chancellor of the Exchequer confirmed the business rate in England would not increase next April.
The nineteen organisations represent a broad cross section of Scottish industry and commerce, including retailers, wholesalers, engineering manufacturing, tourism, hospitality and leisure.
Mr Swinney has not committed to freezing non-domestic rates, but promised to carefully consider the industry's points. The text of Mr Swinney's reply was:
--
Dear David [Londsdale - Director, Scottish Retail Consortium]
Business Rate Poundage
Thanks to you and colleagues for sharing your views on non-domestic rates ahead of the 23-24 Scottish Budget.
I welcome your collective recognition of the scale of the financial challenge that Scotland is facing and the difficult choices ahead. You will be aware that the Office for Budget Responsibility's (OBR) forecasts present a very challenging economic outlook and inflation is having a significant impact on public finances.
Unfortunately, the UK Government Autumn Statement did not go nearly far enough to ensure that the Scottish Government can support people, communities and businesses through the most challenging financial situation since devolution. With confirmation that inflation has risen again to 11.1% and is now at a 41 year high, households and businesses across Scotland are paying a steep price for the economic mismanagement by the UK Government.
On 15 December, I will present my spending plans for next year to the Scottish Parliament as part of the 2023-24 Scottish Budget. This will provide certainty on Scotland’s spending and tax choices, including the poundage, based on our progressive values. In doing so, I will give careful consideration to the points you have put to me in your letter.
Yours sincerely,
John Swinney
--
The text of the industry letter of 23 November read:
--
Dear Deputy First Minister,
We are writing jointly ahead of the Scottish Budget to ask that you do not increase the poundage rate in the coming financial year.
We fully recognise that the Scottish Government, like business, is facing its own costs and inflationary pressures at the present time. We note too that headway has been made in recent years on broader aspects of rates reform including more frequent revaluations, the retention of the uniform business rate, and the pledge to restore parity on the higher property rate with England which should benefit 12,000 commercial premises here in Scotland.
Yet, after two turbulent years of the pandemic the fact is trading conditions remain challenging, the cost of doing business is spiralling, and the near-term economic outlook is weak. Given the decision taken in the UK Autumn Statement we ask that at the very least Scottish Ministers follow suit and similarly freeze the headline business rate poundage in the coming financial year. This would aid firms with the costs crisis, help them keep down prices for customers, and ensure that no more Scottish commercial premises than currently do end up paying a higher business rate than applies down south. It would support business investment and retain Scotland’s competitiveness for most ratepayers.
Our organisations have a range of ideas on how Scotland’s rates system could be improved. However, we collectively believe this practical measure to at least freeze the business rate requires to be taken in your upcoming Scottish Budget, which would be a positive step applicable to all commercial premises and help ease the burden at this difficult time.
Yours sincerely,
David Lonsdale, Director, Scottish Retail Consortium
Sandy Begbie CBE, Chief Executive, Scottish Financial Enterprise
Tracy Black, Director, CBI Scotland
Dr Liz Cameron CBE, Chief Executive, Scottish Chambers of Commerce
Phil Clapp, Chief Executive, UK Cinema Association
Marc Crothall MBE, Chief Executive, Scottish Tourism Alliance
Huw Edwards, CEO, ukactive
Mark Kent, Chief Executive, Scotch Whisky Association
Sarah-Jane Laing, Chief Executive, Scottish Land & Estates
Warrick Malcolm, Director, ADS Scotland
Catherine McWilliam, Nations Director, IoD Scotland
David Melhuish, Director, Scottish Property Federation
Gordon Nelson, Scotland Director, Federation of Master Builders
Garry Richmond, Director, Print Scotland
Paul Sheerin, Chief Executive, Scottish Engineering
Alasdair Smith, Chief Executive, Scottish Bakers
Colin Smith, Chief Executive, Scottish Wholesale Association
David Thomson, Chief Executive, Food & Drink Federation Scotland
Leon Thompson, Executive Director, UKHospitality Scotland
--